In 1985, a small but mighty custard stand opened its doors in West Bend, WI, and quickly became a beloved community staple. That place was Toucan Custard, a local gem known for its delicious frozen treats, classic American eats, and warm, family-friendly atmosphere. For decades, it stood as more than just a restaurant—it was a gathering place, a landmark, and a place where countless memories were made. Now, as we open The Shoppe Custard & Grill, we are honored to keep a piece of that legacy alive and continue the tradition that meant so much to West Bend.
A Nostalgic Piece of West Bend History
If you grew up in or around West Bend, chances are you have fond memories of stopping at Toucan Custard. Maybe it was grabbing a cone after a little league game, enjoying a burger with friends on a summer night, or sitting under the neon glow of the classic toucan sign, savoring every bite of their famous custard. Whatever your memory may be, Toucan Custard wasn’t just about the food—it was about the experience. It was a place where families gathered, first dates happened, and people bonded over simple, delicious meals.
For 27 years Toucan Custard was more than a restaurant; it was part of the heartbeat of Main Street in West Bend. Generations of customers came through its doors, some as kids with their parents and later as parents themselves, introducing their own children to the magic of a frozen custard shop with character. It became a tradition, a part of the town’s identity, and a symbol of good food, good company, and good times.
Carrying the Torch: The Shoppe Custard & Grill
As time moves forward, things change, but that doesn’t mean we forget where we came from. At The Shoppe Custard & Grill, we are honored to step into the space that once held such cherished memories. While we bring our own flavor to the community, we do so with deep respect for what came before us. We recognize the impact that Toucan Custard had on this town, and we are committed to carrying on the spirit of great food, community connection, and a place where everyone feels welcome.
We see ourselves not just as a new restaurant, but as a bridge between the past and the future—a place where nostalgia meets new traditions. Our goal is to honor the history of 600 W. Main St. while giving the next generation a place to make their own lasting memories. Whether you’re stopping in for a scoop of rich, creamy frozen custard, biting into a juicy burger, or just soaking in the small-town charm, we want you to feel the same sense of home that Toucan Custard once provided.
Honoring the Moehr Family Behind the Legacy
A business is nothing without the people behind it, and the Moehr family that ran Toucan Custard played an essential role in shaping the West Bend community. Their hard work, dedication, and passion for quality food and service left an impact that is still felt today. We want to take a moment to recognize and honor them, to express our gratitude for what they built, and to assure the community that their legacy is not forgotten.
To the Moehr family that poured their heart and soul into Toucan Custard, we thank you. We hope to honor your efforts by continuing to provide a warm, welcoming space for the people of West Bend—a place where families can come together, just as they did for decades before.
Keeping Nostalgia Alive
Nostalgia is a powerful thing. It brings us back to the moments that shaped us, the places that made us feel at home, and the simple joys that made life a little sweeter. That’s why, at The Shoppe Custard & Grill, we embrace nostalgia in everything we do. Whether it’s through our classic menu items, our friendly, welcoming service, or even the very walls that hold the memories of the past, we want to create a space that feels both familiar and exciting.
And what’s nostalgia without music? We’re thrilled to introduce our TouchTunes jukebox, where you can pick the songs that bring back memories while enjoying a meal with loved ones. From the greatest hits of the ’80s and ’90s to today’s chart-toppers, we encourage you to set the mood with the music that means the most to you. Just like good food, music has a way of bringing people together, and we’re all about creating those connections.
A New Chapter Begins
As we open our doors, we do so with a deep sense of gratitude. West Bend, you have supported this address for nearly four decades, and we are proud to be part of its story moving forward. We hope that The Shoppe Custard & Grill will be a place where new memories are made, where old traditions continue, and where the spirit of Toucan Custard lives on in every scoop, every bite, and every shared laugh.
So, to the families who once sat at these tables enjoying a custard cone, to the couples who made first-date memories here, and to the generations that grew up with Toucan Custard as part of their lives—we welcome you back. The name may have changed, but the heart remains the same.
Because here at The Shoppe Custard & Grill, we are Always Scoopin’ & Smile’n
